Present: Susan Wright, Jennifer Towler, Alden Bourne, Lise Glading-DiLorenzo, Howard Moore, James Young, Stephanie Pick, Mayor Clare Higgins, Isabelina Rodriguez, Mike Flynn, Edward Zuchowski, Lisa Minnick, Downey Meyer, and Kevin March
I. Roll Call
During the roll call, Mayor Higgins introduced Howard Moore, the newly- elected School Committee member from Ward 3.
II. Organization
1) Election of Vice Chairperson: Stephanie Pick was unanimously elected Vice Chairperson. SP noted that there is a 3-year term limit and that someone needs to get ready to take on the position next year.
2) Election of Executive Secretary: The superintendent was elected Executive Secretary.
3) Adoption of Rules of Procedures: Motion to adopt rules and procedures, with the following changes: elimination of 9.4 (that stipulates all SC members need to return notebooks—members no longer receive notebooks because now most information is electronic); change of 5.2 and 5.5 (which would change the meeting time back to start time of 7:15 p.m.); and elimination of 10.1 (to reflect changes in School Committee’s hiring practices in light of the ed reform bill). Motion to adopt amended rules and procedures passed unanimously.
4) Meeting dates for 2011: Meetings will be held on the second Thursday of every month at 7:15 p.m. for the whole of 2011. There will be three times when there will be three extra full board meetings: one in April for budget purposes, one in May for a joint meeting with the City Council, and one in June for presentation of budget. Calendar was accepted by unanimous vote.
III. Public Session
No public comments.
IV. Announcements
Announcements were about forming subcommittees for the new calendar year and about a farewell party for Isabelina Rodriguez on Thursday, January 27th.
V. Recommended Actions
Minutes from the following committees were approved:
12/2/10 Budget & Property Subcommittee
12/2/10 Curriculum Subcommittee
12/9/10 Full Board Meeting
12/7/10 and 12/14/10 Ad-Hoc Committee
12/16/10 Rules & Policy Subcommittee
VI. Reports and Recommendations
· Northampton High School Representative:
Kevin March, the student representative from Northampton High School, reported that final exams are 1 ½ weeks away, the winter concert is in a week, and the Norway students will go to Woods Hole to do research before their trip.
· Vote: Acknowledgement of Gifts
Vote to accept $17,004 from the Northampton Education Foundation for the SOS Book Fund. These funds were raised through the plant sale and annual census drive. The funds will be distributed to the schools on a per capita basis.
Vote to accept a gift of medical supplies totaling $1787. Nurses from area schools were present to express how helpful the donation will be.
Vote to accept gift of $1,000 to NHS Special Education Department.
· Vote: Acknowledgement of Scholarship
George Zimmerman announced that the estate of Eileen M. Kirby has given $266,000 to establish a scholarship fund at Northampton High School. The interest from this money will support four scholarships for the following areas of study: art studies, fashion, public relations, and engineering. The high school will announce the scholarship in 2012. Mayor Higgins thanked Mr. Zimmerman for managing scholarship investments wisely. Vote to accept this scholarship.
· Report: High School Start Time Proposal
Susan Wright outlined answers to questions the School Committee had asked about the financial implications of starting the high school day at 8 a.m. She reviewed the overall bus schedule and bus costs. The district runs 11 buses, and each one holds 50 to 52 kids and costs about $45,000-plus to run. A three-tier system would not work because of the time needed between each different run (for buses to finish up one route and begin another). Because a three-tier system would not work with an 8 a.m. NHS start time (and later dismissal), the only solution would be to contract for extra buses just for the high school. Four additional buses would cost over $180,000 (this number of buses would allow all current high school bus riders to continue to ride the bus), and if we limited the ridership and ran only three buses, the cost would be closer to $135,000.
During the discussion that ensued, School Committee members asked questions about how Special Education (SPED) transportation would be affected by any changes, about the possibilities of having fewer stops (“satellite stops”) for older kids to make the bus routes shorter, and possible other schedule scenarios. Here is some of the discussion that followed:
Howard Moore: What would happen if elementary school got out earlier? What would happen if NHS and elementary school started at the same time and high school and elementary school students rode the bus together?
SW Capacity is the biggest issue. 400 elementary students ride the buses.
HW: Numbers from last year are lower than the ones Susan Wright is quoting.
SW: We are using current numbers, and there are 393 elementary kids riding buses.
Mayor Higgins: I want to understand where we are going. I want to frame the discussion.
Mike Flynn: We moved to recommend not changing the time.
Mayor Higgins: If we assume for a moment that we need to add buses, how much would it cost?
Alden Bourne: I want to make sure we’ve considered all scenarios. How many kids wouldn’t get to school if we went to the minimum required by law?
SW: If we went to minimum required by law, 700 students would no longer receive transportation. How many students couldn’t get to school is another question.
SP: We wouldn’t make the choice to provide transportation to 6th graders [as required by law] but not 7th and 8th graders [not required by law to receive transportation].
SW: Whoever can’t get to school, we will provide transportation. Hard to determine who would truly be eligible who couldn’t get to school.
James Young: We did not approve the proposal that came before us because we didn’t think it was a good proposal because it disenfranchised people. Here’s another solution. Start JFK at 7:30, NHS at 8:05, and elementary at 8:55. That would be cost neutral.
SW: In order to make that scenario work, the times would need to be later—7:40, 8:15, 9:05—and that would mean NHS students couldn’t get into Smith College courses [the issue is not just getting to the first class on time, but that the class periods at NHS would be out of sync with the day’s class periods at Smith College, if the start time went to 8:10 or 8:15].
There was then a discussion about the relative importance of the Smith College courses (are we giving too much priority to the 80 students who take Smith College courses?), and a few people pointed out that this connection with Smith College alleviates the need for extra electives at NHS. Even without the Smith College consideration, a three-tier bus schedule doesn’t work. One proposal was to have NHS students get out at 2:45 but not be picked up by buses until 3:30 or later. There were two concerns about this: (1) no one would be there to supervise students at the high school (and Lisa Minnick pointed out that the students are the district’s responsibility while on school property and there would be a liability issue) and (2) some parents depend on older children to be home to meet elementary school children.
Mayor Higgins: When does the current bus contract end?
SW: We will be bidding for FY 13.
Kevin March: Existing schedule would work if you switched JFK and NHS start times.
Mayor Higgins: We have a recommendation not to make a change. We now understand the cost implications of making a change [between $135,000 and $180,000-plus, depending on number of buses].
LM: Mr. Moore came up with an alternative plan but I have serious concerns about putting high school students and elementary school students on the bus at the same time.
HM: The numbers work. If you are a high school student who can’t control himself, we have rules to address that.
KM: Ironically, I think the relationship between high school and middle school students might be worse than between high school students and elementary.
MF: [As a teacher,] I see issues on the bus between 2nd graders and 6th graders. Things get said. I wouldn’t be comfortable with any of my kids on the bus with high school students.
Mayor Higgins: Does someone have a motion? Right now we have a recommendation not to change the start times.
Nancy Athas [NHS principal]: If all things were equal, I would be in favor of later start time. But I do have to say that we looked into this trying not to spend extra money. It’s difficult to support later start time if it’s going to cost [close to] $200,000.
SP: It’s incredibly frustrating. We try in every vote to do what’s best for kids, but we can’t find a way to do this [start high school later] and still provide transportation. Every time we can’t do something that we know is good is incredibly frustrating. But we can’t find a way to do this that works for the district.
HM: What would it mean to combine high school and elementary kids on the bus? He makes a motion to ask the administration to explore this possibility, but the motion is not seconded.
Therefore, the start time for Northampton High School and the other schools will remain the same for the coming year.
· Superintendent’s Report
[Here’s a link to a video clip from this part of the meeting, featuring the comments by both Stephanie Pick and Isabelina Rodriguez:
SP asked for the floor and read a tribute to Isabelina Rodriguez honoring her many years of service to the Northampton Public School and her many accomplishments as superintendent.
IR expressed gratitude for the tribute and began her report.
IR: Enrollment numbers look good, though some high school classes are large. (The district had over 30 school choice applications for high school that they had to turn away.) Kindergarten information nights have started, and people are out and about visiting schools. By early March, we should have a handle on who will be registered for fall. There were many kindergarten school choice students this year. Mark Prince [director of curriculum effectiveness] has been working on Race to the Top. He is looking into professional development opportunities. Gwen Agna was honored at the Northampton Survival Center; a parent center is being named in her honor. Bullying plan is on website. Protocols are there, and parents were notified by a connect-ed call about the website. Reporting forms can be found online, and safe school webpage has been updated.
Met with Bill Ericksen [the interim superintendent], and he has attended the administrative leadership team meeting. He will be visiting schools starting tomorrow [January 14]. Confident staff will welcome him warmly.
Met with the administrative team, and they identified the following priorities to focus on during budget discussions: Full special education and ELL continuum across the district, throughout the district; strong support for co-curricular offerings in arts, music, P.E., specials; academic rigor; social/emotional therapeutic support for elementary ed; support for at-risk students at secondary ed; full implementation of the middle school model; support for early literacy for pre-K to 2nd; and class size at or below 20 for pre-K to 2nd.
As you hire an executive officer, be sure he or she is capable to run the district and make hard decisions. Choose a person and then allow him or her to use his or her expertise to run the district. Support the superintendent. Work hard to build level of mutual respect.
IR then concluded her comments by speaking about what an honor and privilege it has been to serve as superintendent and by noting that she will miss her colleagues. She then announced that she has made a donation to the VINS [Volunteers in Northampton Schools] in honor of the School Committee.
· Superintendent Search
SP announced schedule for focus groups for teachers, administrators, parents, and city workers on January 19 and January 20. There will also be focus groups for the School Committee. NESDC (New England School Development Council) will prepare a summary of data from the focus groups.
SP reviewed the search schedule:
Tuesday, January 25th at 6 p.m. NESDC focus group with School Committee. This is an open meeting.
Tuesday, February 1 at 6 p.m. School Committee integration workshop with NESDC for us to have a discussion about all the collated information from the focus groups. Priorities, how we are charging the search committee. This is also an open meeting.
Monday, February 7, from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m. First meeting of the screening committee. First part will be an open session, and the second part will be an executive session during which the screening committee will review procedures and take a confidentiality oath.
Monday, February 14, 6 p.m. to 9 p.m. Closed meeting of the screening committee to discuss all applications and semi-finalists.
· Business Manager’s Report
SW brought five contracts forward for a vote and then reviewed the budget to-date, noting some budgets lines that were over and some that were under—but nothing was terribly unusual or worrying.
Here are some of the highlights from the very thorough report (available in office) SW presented:
(1) Analysis of Fresh Wednesday expenses shows that it’s holding its own. The first Fresh Wednesday incurred additional labor costs, but the December and January Fresh Wednesdays did not have extra labor.
(2) Difficulty in retaining speech therapists in district because speech therapists can get higher salaries in hospitals, and we pay teachers’ scale for speech therapy. IR commented that we need to look at different model for speech therapy.
(3) Capital Plan for updating cafeterias
(4) 1.5 million in school choice funds this year. $245,000 used for additional preschool teacher and additional ESPs. $396,000 will roll into next year’s budget. Also, $169,000 in circuit breaker funds will roll over.
(5) Stimulus grants will be gone in FY12.
(6) Sub costs are lower so far this year.
(7) After school programs running in black. Jackson Street is starting up after school program in spring.
Curriculum Subcommittee Report
Nothing new to report, in the process of rescheduling a meeting.
Building and Properties.
BPS meeting with school councils scheduled for January 19.
Rules and Policies
Needs to meet one more time before finalizing vote.
VII. New Business
(1) SP will populate the subcommittees and all other committees.
(2) IR thanked the DPW and custodial staff for making sure schools were ready for school today [1/13—day after the snow day on 1/12].
(3) JY observed that the School Committee tends to have such packed agendas that they don’t always get to talk about new things. He then held up a book called Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation will Change the Way the World Learns (by Clayton Chirstensen et al) about the use of technology in schools: leveraging it to change how we deliver education in school. Would like to spend time talking about innovative ideas. Mayor Higgins said that she and SP will talk about a structure for addressing long-term goals and innovative ideas in the meetings, with the plan to put these ideas on an agenda for a future meeting.
Meeting adjourned shortly after 10 p.m.